.357 Magnum is generally considered more powerful and has greater potential for deeper penetration than the .45 ACP, making it more effective for hunting and potentially more lethal in that context. MeatEater +4
45 Auto is usually loaded with bullets between 185 and 230 grains. Despite its lighter bullets, the . 357 Mag. usually produces more energy and offers a better trajectory.
357 Magnum or other similar-caliber load, a well-placed shot with a good bullet will certainly kill a bear, but it's not recommended. Wayne Bosowicz carried a Colt Python . 357 Magnum revolver for years as his bear gun.
The correct answer to what gun has the most recoil will depend on the specific firearm type we are talking about. For instance, among pistols, the Desert Eagle is famous for its felt recoil, while among rifles, the Barrett M82A1 . 50 caliber probably takes the cake.
You are right to be concerned about such things -- the 1911 is notorious for jamming frequently. Specifically the ejector mechanism; if the gun is not held steady after firing, the spent cartridge tends to get jammed between the barrel and the slide.
SIG SAUER® Infinite Guarantee™
The P226 MK25 is identical to the pistol carried by the U.S. Navy SEALs, the fleet's special warfare operators. The railed P226 chambered in 9mm and engraved with an anchor on the left side of the slide is the official sidearm of the SEALs.
Most Powerful Handguns
357 magnum chronographed 6% lower velocities and energy (1090 fps, 329 ft/lbs) in the same bullet weight from effectively the same barrel length as the 9mm revolver, while producing much more (painful) recoil and muzzle blast.
357 magnum rounds might achieve higher velocity simply because they can fire bullets that are lighter than those of the Glock 10mm. In FBI ballistic gel testing, the . 357 was an overachiever. It overpenetrated in comparison to the 10mm handgun cartridge.
The . 357 Magnum rifle is a highly capable firearm for a variety of hunting applications. Its performance in handling different game types ranges from small vermin to deer and, potentially, even larger game such as black bear.
It is still powerful and will provide the necessary stopping power in a home defense or self-defense situation. You could also go for a compact K-frame or a Ruger SP101 snub nose. Keep in mind that although the gun is small enough for concealed carry, it will be heavier than a typical . 38 Spl.
Yes, a 45 ACP can kill a bear, but it has some significant flaws. First, it lacks the recommended striking energy to stop bears instantly. Second, it doesn't have many hard cast bullet options, so it will rarely penetrate deep enough to stop a charging bear.
The Heckler & Koch HK45C is a compact, . 45 ACP caliber pistol that has found favor with some Navy SEALs for its stopping power and ergonomic design. This handgun features a modular grip and ambidextrous controls, allowing for customization and ease of use by operators with different preferences.
Many believe that the 10mm Auto has the advantage when used for backcountry survival or bear defense. This seems logical given its ballistic advantage. However, if the right loads are used the 45 Auto might be the better choice.
The deadliest 45 ACP ammo is loaded with +P 230 grain JHP (but all 45 ACP ammo is deadly).
In its non-expanding full metal jacket (FMJ) version, the .45 ACP cartridge has a reputation for effectiveness against human targets because of its heavy mass, having the capacity to penetrate tissue deeply, and damage the central nervous system.
While in combat, Chris chose the Springfield Armory TRP™ for its reliable performance and toughness. In his words in best-selling book, American Sniper, he tells how that TRP™ may have saved his life.
Lethality of the Caliber
Larger handgun calibers, though used less frequently, tend to be more lethal. For example, . 357 caliber has an 88% higher fatality rate compared to non-fatal shootings;. 45 caliber, a 67% higher fatality rate.
That means the 10mm has over 50% more recoil than the 45 ACP. That difference will feel pretty substantial to many shooters. Several variables can increase or decrease recoil.
300-Magnum rifle or a 12-gauge shotgun with rifled slugs are appropriate weapons if you have to shoot a bear. Heavy handguns such as a .
45 ACP pistols, are popular choices for bear defense. These handguns are lighter and more compact, which makes them easier to carry, and they recoil less, which makes them easier to shoot. It might surprise you that Sundles prefers the . 45 ACP to the 10 mm Auto for bear defense.
Though able to make effective use of the MK-12, Kyle more often used a similar weapon, the MK11 Special Purpose Rifle. Also known as the SR-25, the MK11 is a scaled-up version of the M16, chambered for the larger 7.62 x 51mm cartridge, known to civilian hunters as the . 308.
THE QUICK LIST
The 357 Magnum is renowned for its exceptional power and high velocity, making it effective for self-defense, hunting medium-sized game, and even some large game with the proper load. It produces significantly higher muzzle energy than the 45 Long Colt in most standard factory loads.